What Makes A Work Of Art - 777 Words

Collingwood starts his essay by answering the question of what is a work of art. According to Collingwood, art is a habitual process. To further explain the habitual process, Collingwood compares art’s habitual creation to the human’s habitual process of speech. While discussing art, he mentions that there are two theories that impose his own; however, he doesn’t believe to argue on them because it’s theorization and requires a person actually to solve it before arguing against it. However, Collingwood notes that theories have a similarity to art, and that is the process of creation. The next section of his essay discusses making and creating. Collingwood believes â€Å"the act of procreation is a voluntary act, and those who do it are responsible for what they are doing, but it not done by any specialized form of skill.† However, when it comes to a person who creates things regarding â€Å"acting voluntarily† and thus assumes a role of responsibility, rather than peruse any ulterior ends and motives, it is not a process of â€Å"raw† creation. Thus, the artist is aware he/she does not make anything according to a preconceived plan, nor are they â€Å"imposing a new form upon a given matter.† However, God, on the other hand, is able to create things out of nothing and thus can impose a new form. With this distinction, Collingwood can show the difference between the artist as a creator and God. The section titled Creation and Imagination attempts to explain the process of creation. CollingwoodShow MoreRelatedWhat Is A Theory Of Art?1446 Words   |  6 Pagesmust be met for something to be an artwork. What are these criteria? What is the difficulty with the first two criteria that led him to offer the third and final criteria. What is a theory of art? Why might one think these criteria lead to a circular theory of art? Why would one be wrong in this assessment? Critics have been trying to determine what exactly the definition art is for many years now. Throughout history, identifying what was art and what was not was presumed to be obvious. ThereforeRead MoreEssay on The Many Forms of Art1146 Words   |  5 Pagesreveal, to order and disorder, with or without a purpose. Yet the definition of what is art is obscure, we are able to recognise for ourselves but not express concisely what art is. Art has ‘a complicated network of overlapping series of similarities’ (Law, 2003) however there is not one feature that all art has in common. The classification of Art does not fit into the classic logic argument where to be defined as art the object must have a stated characteristic, as in the manner of classifyingRead MoreAisha Osman. Matthew Brogden. Engl 3001W: Textual Analysis1535 Words   |  7 PagesIn Tradition and the Individual Talent, T.S. Eliot makes an argument against artists expressing their own emotions and their own personal experiences to a work of art. Eliot goes into detail in how personal experiences in a work of art would essentially be pushing your own emotions on to the reader whether they want them or not. He also highlights the benefits of allowing the text to speak for itself, in a sense. Eliot believes that true art is art that can give its own emotions without the input ofRead MoreReview Of The Principles Of Art 988 Words   |  4 PagesCollingwood begins â€Å"The Principles of Art† by determining to define what is a work of art. He suggests it is made, but not by turning a medium in to some thing, and not by use of planning. Here Collingwood considers that it should be determined what sort of â€Å"making† it is when art is made. It is not construction, like a bridge, nor is it accidental. In the past, it was thought that neither the skill of the artist nor his conscious mind had anything to do with art, for it was inspiration given by GodRead MoreThe Problem Defined By In Collingswood s Essay908 Words   |  4 Pagesdefined: In Collingswood’s essay, he begins with a question on what is a work of art. He defines this idea by asking two questions on the origin of the art (which is not made of altering a raw material) and of the artist. First he discusses the artist, and how the art is composed. He remarks that something is controlling the artist and what it might be and elaborates that it is not the artist skill but the control that is producing the art. This control can be thought of as inspiration but leavesRead MoreArt : Art And Art1744 Words   |  7 PagesWhat is it that attracts us to art? Have you ever wondered exactly why abstract art displays in art museums are indefinitely more valued than that of an art piece created by a child? If you happen to be unaware of what abstract art is all about, it is the only art form in which is solely based upon creating art using shapes, forms, colors and lines to create a composition designed to have no aesthetic significance whatsoever. In this, it is meant that abstract art is completely detached from realityRead MoreThe Important Elements Of Art1423 Words   |  6 PagesArt historians work just like real detectives, they quest for valuable information about a work of art and its history. The detective work is very vital for many reasons for example information about a work of art can help determine the value of the art as well as its meaning. One the other hand, the human eye is incredible sometimes we take for granted because it allows us to see pictures as a whole rather than in parts. And yet, images like painting and drawings can be broken down into specificRead MoreEssay on Art and the Bible1429 Words   |  6 PagesArt and the Bible Art and the Bible is an interesting approach at looking at art in all of its forms. It also answers the question what is the place of art in the Christian life? Along with the question it tries to put a general perspective on art. The different types of art that are mentioned are writing, painting, poetry, drama and music. The question is answered by looking in the Bible and finding specific example regarding art in all of its forms. The general perspectives on art are lookedRead MoreWhat Is Art?, And Marcel Duchamp s The Creative Act1067 Words   |  5 PagesToday day, art still is a controversial subject of aesthetics, in discussing whether variety form of modern visual art is art or not. In Laurie Schneider Adams’ article â€Å"What is Art?† and Marcel Duchamp’s â€Å"The Creative Act†, they have own criteria to definite what the nature of art, its meaning and its function. In evaluation Doris Salcedo’s art work Atrabilious, a set of worn shoe s encased in rectangle niches on the wall. I agree with their explanation of art thought the combined in structure andRead MoreEssay On The NEA919 Words   |  4 Pages Every day we see art whether it is a pattern, sculpture, or even a picture. Art is everywhere. For artists to show their work they would go under the government process of the NEA. This program is wonderful on what they do with art. The government funding of art through the NEA is beneficial which helps art programs increase with money donations, the right to express your freedom, and lastly to show the public what they are wanting to see. The NEA helps art programs increase with money donations